2026-11-13

Sixty years ago today (November 13, 1966), the Foreign Investors Tax Act of 1966 (FITA) was enacted. FITA added new subsections 864(b) and (c). Code §864(c)(5)(C) contained a typo. Subparagraph (C) provided in part:
[T]he income * * * which shall be attributable to an office * * * within the United States shall be the income * * * property allocable thereto * * *.
From the context, it is clear that Congress meant "properly allocable" and not "property allocable". Furthermore, footnote 4 of proposed regulations published in 2019 provides:
Section 864(c)(5)(C) actually states "the income, gain or loss property [sic] allocable thereto." Based on the legislative history behind The Foreign Investors Tax Act, Public Law 89-809 (1966), which added section 864(c) to the Code, the use of "property" in the final bill appears to be a typographical error. The Senate Report that added this provision used the word "properly" not "property." See S. Rep. No. 1707 at 1275 (1966).
The Cornell version of the Code, the house.gov version of the Code, and the Checkpoint version of the Code all use the word "property" in Code §864(c)(5)(C). In contrast, my printed version of the Code from CCH since at least 2015 uses the term "properly".
Congress should fix the typo because a court recently interpreted Code §864 as not containing the phrase "properly allocable". In Keysight Technologies, Inc. v. United States, No. 25-137 (Fed. Cl. July 2, 2026), the Court of Federal Claims stated:
Sections 861(b) and 904(d) mention "properly allocable" in passing, but Section 864 does not. Compare I.R.C. § 861(b) ("properly apportioned or allocated thereto") with I.R.C. § 864 (references "allocable" but omits "properly") * * *.
It would be helpful if Congress were to fix the typo it made 60 years ago with a technical correction of the statute.